Sendwell
All posts

The welcome series playbook for small online businesses

What a welcome series is for, the four emails I'd start with and when to send them, how to split it by subscriber type, and the mistakes I'd avoid.

Billy at Sendwell5 min read

The moment someone joins your list is the most interested they'll ever be in your brand. They just raised their hand. A welcome series is how you use that moment, and for most small online businesses it's one of the first two flows I'd build.

In this playbook I'll walk through what the series should do, the four emails I'd start with and when to send them, how to adjust for different kinds of subscribers, and the mistakes I'd avoid. Treat the timings and copy outlines as a starting point to test, not a formula.

What a welcome series is for

It has three jobs: deliver what you promised at signup, introduce your brand in a way that's worth remembering, and turn some subscribers into first-time buyers. It triggers when someone subscribes, and it should not run for people who are already customers.

The numbers support giving it priority. Klaviyo's benchmarks, as summarised by 8x, show an average of about $2.65 in revenue per recipient, with the top decile at $21.18. Stripo's research, which combines figures from several email vendors, finds that intent peaks at signup and fades fast: sending immediately beats sending later. It also reports that a short series of one to three emails generates about 51% more total revenue than a single email, even though each later email is opened less.

Those are vendor figures and directional only, but they point the same way as common sense. Send quickly, and send more than one email.

The four emails I'd start with

The timings and subject lines below are my own starting suggestions, not figures from a study. The sources agree on a short series and an immediate first send, and the rest is worth testing on your own list.

#SendJobSubject line ideasWhat goes in it
1Straight awayDeliver what you promised"Here's your 10% off" or "Welcome to [Brand]: your guide inside"The code or freebie first, one line on who you are, one clear button. Nothing else competing.
2Day 1 or 2Tell your story"Why we started [Brand]" or "What makes ours different"Your reason for existing, one or two proof points, and a link to your most representative product.
3Day 3 or 4Show what to buy"Our most-loved picks" or "Start here"Best sellers or a short quiz-style guide, with reviews and a clear pointer to where to begin.
4Day 6 or 7Answer the hesitation and nudge"Still thinking it over?" or "Your offer ends soon"Delivery, returns and fit questions answered, plus a reminder of any offer and its end date, but only if the end date is real.

I'd write the first email to be short enough to read on a phone in ten seconds. If your product needs more education, expand email 2 or 3 rather than adding a fifth email. Add more only after you've seen how many people still open the fourth.

Who should get which version

The simplest version of the series is one path for everyone. That's a fine place to start. When you're ready to branch, these are the splits I'd try first, in this order:

  1. Existing customers versus new. Don't send a first-order discount to someone who has already bought. Exclude them, or give them a shorter series with no new-customer offer.
  2. Where they signed up. Someone who joined from a pop-up on a product page wants that product. Someone who joined at checkout is probably already a customer. Match the first email to what they were doing.
  3. Incentive or no incentive. Delivering the promised incentive in the first email and saving brand story and education for the later ones is the common pattern, as Omnisend's guide to welcome emails describes. Whether to offer a discount at all is a business decision. It buys first orders, but it can also attract people who only buy on discount, so I'd test it against a version that leads with value instead.

Stop there. Each branch doubles the number of emails you have to write and maintain, and the benefit is small until your list is big enough to measure it.

Mistakes I'd avoid

  • Sending the first email late. Intent fades fast, as Stripo's research notes. If your platform delays the send by hours, fix that first.
  • Not delivering what you promised. If the sign-up form offered a code or a guide, it must be in email 1, easy to find and easy to copy.
  • Writing one long email. Four short emails with one job each beat one email that tries to do everything.
  • Sending to people who didn't consent. Under the Spam Act, you need consent, a clear sender identity and a working unsubscribe, as the ACMA explains. Keep a record of how and when each person signed up.
  • Judging it by open rate. Apple's Mail Privacy Protection can mark emails as opened without anyone reading them, so welcome-email open rates, which are often very high, can't be taken at face value. Use clicks and orders instead.

What to measure and what good looks like

The main number is revenue per recipient: the revenue the series earned divided by the number of people who entered it. The benchmark to keep in mind is about $2.65 on average and $21.18 for the top decile, according to Klaviyo figures as summarised by 8x. For context, Klaviyo reports an average click rate of 5.58% across all flows. Those are averages across many industries, and some come from earlier years, so compare your own series against its previous version before you compare it against anyone else's.

Alongside revenue, I'd check each email's click rate and orders, how many people unsubscribe after each email, and whether spam complaints stay low. If email 4 earns almost nothing and attracts most of the unsubscribes, shorten the series.

Where to start this week

Write email 1 and make sure it sends within minutes of signup. That alone fixes the most common problem. If you'd like me to look over your current welcome series, book a free 15-minute call and I'll go through it with you: pick a time here.

Sources

Want a second pair of eyes on your emails?

Book a free 15-minute call. We go through where you're at and you leave with a clear next step.