The abandoned cart email playbook for small online businesses
Why shoppers abandon carts, the three-email sequence I'd start with, whether to offer a discount, who to leave out, and what good looks like.
Every abandoned cart is a customer who got most of the way to buying. They picked a product, they gave you their email address, and then something got in the way. A short sequence of well-timed emails is the cheapest way I know to go back and ask what it was.
In this playbook I'll cover why people abandon carts, the three-email sequence I'd start with, whether to offer a discount, who should be left out, and the mistakes I'd avoid. As with any flow, treat the timings and copy as a starting point to test.
Why people leave, and what email can fix
Baymard Institute has pulled together 50 studies and puts the average documented cart abandonment rate at 70.22% (updated September 2025). Part of that is natural behaviour: people use carts to compare prices, save things for later or just browse. Excluding the "just browsing" group, the leading reasons shoppers gave were:
- 40%: unexpected extra costs such as shipping, taxes or fees
- 20%: delivery was too slow
- 19%: they didn't trust the site with their card details
- 18%: the site required them to create an account
- 17%: the checkout was too long or complicated
- 17%: website errors or crashes
Email can help with some of these. A reminder can answer a delivery or returns question, restate shipping costs clearly, or simply catch someone who was interrupted. It can't fix a checkout that forces account creation or throws errors. If your abandonment is unusually high, check the checkout itself before blaming your emails.
The three emails I'd start with
Klaviyo's own guidance is to send two or three abandoned cart messages, with the first two to four hours after checkout starts and the second 20 to 48 hours later. Its benchmark report suggests three emails at roughly 2–4 hours, 24 hours and 48 hours. I'd follow that pattern. The subject lines and copy outlines below are my suggestions to test.
| # | Send | Job | Subject line ideas | What goes in it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2–4 hours after | A helpful reminder | "Still thinking about it?" or "You left something behind" | The exact items, with image, size or colour, and price. One "return to cart" button. No discount. |
| 2 | About 24 hours after | Remove doubts | "Questions before you buy?" or "Free returns on your order" | Delivery times, returns, warranty and a few short reviews of the items in the cart. Your support contact. |
| 3 | About 48 hours after | A last, low-pressure nudge | "Last chance to grab your picks" or "Your cart is about to expire" | The cart again, and, if you use one, the incentive. Alternative products if the item is low on stock or out. |
The first email is the one most likely to do the work, so spend your time on it. An older Barilliance study from 2016 across 200 stores also found that a first email sent within an hour converted better than one delayed to 24 hours. It's dated, so I'd use it only as a nudge to test an earlier first send if your platform allows it.
Discount or no discount
You don't need a discount to run this flow. Klaviyo's benchmark report says discounts aren't mandatory and suggests offering an incentive only on higher-value carts, where a sale is worth more to you. Its flow guide recommends avoiding discounts in the first email and saving any incentive for the final message or for first-time purchasers.
My view, which is judgement and not data, is that a code sent to everyone who abandons teaches regular customers to abandon on purpose. If margins allow an offer, I'd make it conditional, such as a minimum cart value, a first-time buyer, or email 3 only, and test it against a no-discount version.
Who should be left out
Getting the exclusions right matters as much as the copy. Klaviyo's flow guide lists two filters I'd set up on day one: exclude anyone who has placed an order since starting the flow, and add a rule so the same person doesn't re-enter the flow too often. It also recommends showing only the abandoned items.
If you use Shopify's built-in abandoned checkout emails, the Shopify Help Center says they are not sent when the customer completes the purchase first, when they gave only a phone number, or when the products are out of stock. Running a built-in flow and a separate platform flow at the same time risks double-sending, so use one.
On consent, a reminder about a specific cart is closer to a service message than a promotion. Once you add offers it looks like marketing, and the Spam Act's rules on consent, sender identification and unsubscribe apply to commercial messages, as the ACMA explains. I'm not a lawyer, so if you're unsure how your flow is classified, get advice, and include an unsubscribe link either way.
Mistakes I'd avoid
- Sending too late. The first email should go within hours, not the next day. Use the 2–4 hour guidance as your default and test earlier.
- Leading with a discount. It cuts your margin on carts that would have converted anyway.
- Showing the wrong things. The email should show exactly what was in the cart, with price and image, and not a generic best-seller grid.
- Emailing people who already bought. An exclusion for placed orders is the single most important filter.
- Sending too many. Two or three emails is what Klaviyo's research supports. Beyond that, each extra email adds unsubscribe risk, so I'd only add more once you can see the third one still earning.
- Ignoring the checkout. If shoppers keep leaving over shipping costs or forced account creation, as Baymard's data shows is common, no email sequence will fully fix it.
What to measure and what good looks like
Klaviyo's abandoned cart benchmark report analysed more than 143,000 flows sent in 2023. It's the most useful reference I found, but it's a few years old and covers many industries, so use it for scale and not as a target.
| Metric | Average | Top 10% |
|---|---|---|
| Click rate | 6.25% | 13.33% |
| Conversion rate | 3.33% | 7.69% |
| Revenue per recipient | $3.65 | $28.89 |
The report also lists an average open rate of 50.5%. I'd ignore it, because Apple's Mail Privacy Protection can record opens that never happened. Track clicks, orders and revenue per recipient for each email in the sequence, plus unsubscribes and spam complaints, and compare your results with your own previous version first.
Where to start this week
Set up email 1 with the exact cart contents and no discount, add the placed-order exclusion, and send it 2–4 hours after checkout starts. If you'd like me to review your current abandoned cart flow, book a free 15-minute call and I'll go through it with you: pick a time here.
Sources
- Baymard Institute: cart abandonment rate statistics (updated September 2025)
- Klaviyo: abandoned cart benchmark report
- Klaviyo Help Center: how to create an abandoned cart flow
- Shopify Help Center: abandoned checkouts
- Barilliance: cart abandonment emails benchmark study (2016)
- ACMA: avoid sending spam
Want a second pair of eyes on your emails?
Book a free 15-minute call. We go through where you're at and you leave with a clear next step.